January 4, 2008
In the Republican caucuses in Iowa, voters practiced democracy.
Republicans got to vote for the candidate of their choice and to have
their votes counted. Democrats weren't so lucky. Each
Democratic candidate had to get 15% at each caucus gathering. If
a Democratic candidate got 14.999% at a caucus, that 14.999% counted
for 0.000%. That candidate's supporters were told to go home or
back another Democratic candidate. This artificially boosted some
results while depriving viable candidates of any genuine indicator of
their true support.
The Democratic caucuses were undemocratic in others ways. The
numbers of delegates were preassigned to each caucus and the number
didn't change whether 2 people showed up or 1000 showed up. For
example, suppose caucuses in districts 1 and 2 were assigned 2
delegates. Suppose 10,0000 Kucinich supporters showed up in
district 1 but didn't constitute 15%. The result would be that he
lost all those delegates. Suppose district 2 had a low showing
where the top winner only had 10 delegates show up. The votes of
those 10 delegates would count more than the 10,000 votes of the
Kucinich delegates in the first district.
Knowing that the Democratic caucuses were undemocratic, several
candidates who had been denied media publicity asked their delegates to
back Barack Obama on the second vote. The fact that several
candidates picked Obama for their second did not go unnoticed.
George Stephanopoulos referred to this as anti-Edwards. From
speaking with supporters of various candidates, members of the Creative
Youth News Team have confirmed that supporters urging candidates to do
this were more opposed to John Edwards than supportive of Obama.
Edwards has alienated a lot of voters with his aristocratic ways and
his attempts to fix the debates by limiting the number of
participants. The news media has pushed Edwards and allowed him
to have his way in cutting candidates, particularly anti-war
candidates, out of the debates.
Several caucus-goers have pointed out that Obama's 38% finish was a
misleading tally and related to the number of delegates assigned to
each district. In reality, close to 50% of caucus-goers picked
Obama on the second round. Edwards and Clinton finished low in an
almost tie, 2/10s of a percentage point apart.
For John Edwards, a low second-place tie was a major loss.
Edwards has spent much of recent years trying to woo the Iowa voters to
his cause. He has spent millions in Iowa and millions have been
spent by others on his behalf, there. Edwards was heavily
promoted by the mass media while others candidates were either
criticized or largely ignored. Edwards had been counting on a
first place finish and a number of speculators expected him to drop out
of the race if he didn't finish a high first. Making the best of
his loss, Edwards acted as if it were a win. One observer
commented that Edwards is great at spinning things. He could
convince a jury that black is white. Many independent observers
felt that Iowa was his best shot and that he needed Iowa to propel him
to victory elsewhere.
On the Republican side, where the voting was much more democratic, Mike
Huckabee won a runaway first place and soundly defeated Mitt Romney,
whose former Utah finance director among others on his campaign, was
tied to schools sued for torture and for physical, mental and sexual
abuse of children. To America's youth, the defeat of Romney was a
big win in Iowa.
In almost a dead heat for third were Fred Thompson, John McCain, and
Ron Paul. Ron Paul is an Internet superstar and fundraising
champion who is expected to do well in other states that are more
impacted by the war in Iraq. A number of states have stood
against the Patriot Act and Paul is expected to do exceedingly well in
those states. Paul opposed both the war in Iraq and the Patriot
Act.
The undemocratic nature of the Iowa caucus system is one of many
reasons Democrats, nationwide, are calling for a national
primary. Most expect this to be the last year Iowa has the first
say.
Copyright ©2008 by the Creative
Youth
News Team. All rights reserved.
Home